Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Create Your Own Pizza Small
Lobster Ravioli
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Minestrone Soup
About
Tuscany NY Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Welcome to Tuscany NY Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, a culinary gem nestled in Lumberton, North Carolina. This vibrant eatery invites you to indulge in the flavorful world of Italian cuisine, boasting a delightful menu that celebrates authenticity and tradition. Located conveniently at 1810 N Pine St, Tuscany has quickly gained a reputation among locals and travelers alike, offering more than just a meal—it's a genuine Italian experience.
Stepping through Tuscany's doors, you're greeted by warm decor and a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for a family dinner or a special date night. Each dish is crafted with the freshest ingredients, reflecting the true essence of Italy. Whether you're craving a classic Lasagna, which one satisfied customer declared the best they've ever tasted, or a rich Chicken Marsala paired with delicate angel hair pasta, you’re in for a treat.
Highlights of the menu also include the scrumptious Shrimp Scampi and hearty Pasta Fagioli, praised by customers for their robust flavors. One diner noted the challenges of a strong bean taste but still found joy in the overall excellence of the dish. The generous portions of Garlic Bread served alongside are perfect for sharing or savoring on your own.
And let’s not forget the pizza! From a Large Supreme that leaves guests raving about its fresh toppings to the establishment’s signature pies, Tuscany knows how to deliver on flavor. Customers have noted that each bite is a burst of cheesy goodness and tasty toppings, all baked to perfection.
The service at Tuscany NY is as commendable as the food. Guests have lauded the attentive staff who ensure your dining experience is nothing short of spectacular. Servers like Jordyn are mentioned specifically for their delightful and accommodating nature, making every visit memorable.
In summary, Tuscany NY Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is the ideal destination for anyone in search of outstanding Italian fare in Lumberton. With rave reviews highlighting its quality dishes, attentive service, and inviting ambiance, Tuscany is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary journey that you simply can't miss.
So, whether you're traveling through or a local looking to indulge, treat yourself to a meal that celebrates the best of Italian cuisine. Make a reservation or simply drop by; you won't regret the experience!
For inquiries, don’t hesitate to call +1 910-536-1220.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Jordyn was Amazing! Thank you for making our date night so special she was so attentive and delightful with a sweet personality we will make sure to ask for her every time we return. Thank you Jordyn ”
“ This place is a hidden gem! Very fast, friendly staff. And the food is served fresh as well. Authentic flavor! Definitely recommend coming here! ”
“ Tuscany NY Italian Restaurant and Pizza never disappoints! The food is absolutely delicious — their pizza is next level, with that perfect crisp and flavor that keeps you coming back. I was especially impressed with the pepper steak — tender, flavorful, and cooked just right. Even the side of fries stands out — a generous portion, seasoned perfectly, and super satisfying. Everything is well-prepared and seriously appetizing. Highly recommend! ”
“ Absolutely Delicious!!! The server was knowledgeable about the menu and attentive to our needs. Food was Amazing! We will definitely be returning. ”
“ Husband and I ate here for the first time today, we ordered a Large Supreme pizza. The pizza was great. Restaurant a little on the cold size compared to most restaurants. Overall good experience. ”
“ Best lasagna ever! My first time here but I WILL be back! Perfect sauce and cheese. I couldn't have been more pleased. ”
“ We stopped when in town for the first time. Finally found this Italian place. Our food and service was outstanding, can’t wait to go back and try another dish. I had the Chicken Marsala with angle hair, delicious. My wife had the Chicken Contadina, she loved it as well. We shared the Mussels Marinara. The were very tasty as well. Our server was awesome, very attentive and willing to please. Can’t wait for our return, thanks everyone! One of the best meals we have had in Lumberton, we have stopped at least 20 times on the way back from Florida.. 6/5/25 back again. Still 5 stars for food and service. Curran took care of us and provided excellent service. This time I had the pasta fagioli soup which was excellent. I also had the baked ziti and that too was awesome. My wife had a hogie which was very tasty. We will be back again to try some more dishes. Thanks. ”
“ First time eating here and I'll be back. The Shrimp Scampi was real good. The Pasta fagoil was good. Had enough of garlic bread for two other people and the side salad with the house dressing was tasty. The one thing that throwed me off was the fagoil. It had a strong bean taste but other than that, it was excellent ”